top of page

Squats or Quad Extensions - Which Is Better for Muscle Growth?

Nov 9
2 min read

If you've spent any time around a gym, you've heard both sides. Squats are the king of lower body exercises and safer on your knees than quad extensions. Or, quad extensions are a perfectly good way to isolate the quads, and they're easier on the lower back and way easier to learn.


So who's right?


A new study (https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42570108/) put the question to a direct test. Twenty-four untrained participants were split into a squat group and a quad extension group. Both trained for ten weeks. The researchers measured the knee extensors before and after, and the result?


Both groups got stronger. Both groups put on muscle thickness. But...


The squat group still came out ahead. Muscle thickness increased more in the squat group than the quad extension group. And only the squat group showed increases in measures of how the muscle is physically built, meaning it can produce more force.


If this result sounds a little contradictory, given that quad extensions are such good isolators of the quad muscles themselves, you're not alone. So why the result? The authors suggest that to hold a given load in a squat, the knee has to produce a high amount of torque. The squat demands more from the knee extensors because of how load-bearing it is, and the muscle responds by adapting more.


Now this doesn't mean quad extensions are useless or unsafe. They still allow quad training that takes pressure off the lower back, and still produce growth. Just not quite as much as squats.


If your goal is lower body strength, and you can squat with good mechanics, make a squat pattern the foundation of your leg training. It builds more muscle, produces more torque, and carries over to the single-joint exercise much better than the reverse. But if squatting is temporarily off the table because of pain, mobility, or injury, a quad extension still builds strength and muscle.

 
 

Recent Posts

See All
Does Red Light Therapy Heal Stress Fractures?

If you've spent any time around wellness influencer's feed, you've seen the glowing red panels. Red light therapy (the fancy word is photobiomodulation) gets pitched for just about everything, includi

 
 
Can Dark Chocolate Lower Your Blood Pressure?

Calling dark chocolate (around 70-80% cacao) a health food might sound like a loophole somebody made up to sell more chocolate, but a new study shows there's real data behind it. A new study (https://

 
 
bottom of page